🔍 Phase 3 — Investigation 🔬 Group B 📋 DEAR Framework ⏱ 15 minutes

Task 5 — The Art Critic: "Reading a Painting"

Welcome, Art Critic! Your mission is to analyse a masterpiece in depth using the DEAR framework. Distinguish between what you objectively see and what you subjectively interpret — then craft one sentence that captures it all.

Your Mission

🔬

Four steps to becoming an Art Critic

Choose a masterpiece → Observe it in silence (60 seconds) → Complete the DEAR analysis (Describe, Examine, Analyse, Respond) → Write one Critique Sentence that synthesises everything. Your group output will be saved to your shared portfolio and presented in Phase 5.

The DEAR Framework

Describe

What do you see objectively? Colours, shapes, composition, subject — facts only.

Start with: "I see…", "There is…", "The colours are…"

Examine

How is the work composed? Movement, balance, emphasis, light — the structure.

Start with: "The artist guides the gaze…", "The composition is…"

Analyse

What meaning or message does it communicate? Emotion, symbolism, intention.

Start with: "This evokes…", "It symbolises…", "The artist communicates…"

Respond

What is your personal response? Connection, critical judgement, what it made you think.

Start with: "I find myself…", "This questions me…", "The work made me think of…"

Step 1 — Choose a Masterpiece

🖼 Select the artwork your group will analyse. You can zoom in for fine detail once selected. All works are displayed at high resolution with full context.

🌙

The Starry Night

Van Gogh · 1889 · Post-Impressionism

Selected

🎩

The Son of Man

Magritte · 1964 · Surrealism

Selected

💎

Girl with a Pearl Earring

Vermeer · 1665 · Baroque

Selected

🏚

American Gothic

Wood · 1930 · Realism

Selected

⏰

The Persistence of Memory

Dalí · 1931 · Surrealism

Selected

📖

The Artist's Daughter Reading

Sargent · 1910 · Impressionism

Selected

🌙

—

Checkpoint 1 — Why did you choose this work? (max. 80 chars)

✅ Saved

Step 2 — Silent Observation (60 seconds)

🤫

60 seconds — just look. Don't write yet.

Observe the work in silence. Notice colours, shapes, light, texture, mood. Where does your eye travel first? What feeling arises before you start thinking?

⏳ 60 seconds to observe

Step 3 — DEAR Analysis

Describe — What do you see?

Objective observation only · max. 250 characters

Describe the colours, shapes, composition and subject of the work. State only what you can objectively observe — no interpretation yet.

💡 Start with: "I see…", "There is…", "The colours are…", "In the foreground…"

Checkpoint 2 — Most important detail "In your description, which detail do you think is most important for understanding the work?" (max. 100 chars)

Examine — How is it organised?

Composition, movement, balance, light · max. 250 characters

How does the artist organise space, direct your gaze, balance the composition? Consider movement, repetition, emphasis and contrast.

💡 Start with: "The artist guides the gaze…", "The composition is…", "There is repetition of…", "The light falls on…"

Checkpoint 3 — How does the artist guide your gaze? Describe the path your eye takes through the work. (max. 120 chars)

Analyse — What does it mean?

Emotion, symbolism, artist's intention · max. 300 characters

What emotion, meaning or message does the work communicate? Go beyond description into interpretation — what was the artist trying to express?

💡 Start with: "This evokes…", "It symbolises…", "The artist communicates…", "The technique reflects…", "The use of [element] suggests…"

Checkpoint 4 — Central emotion or message "What is the central emotion or message the work conveys?" (max. 150 chars)

Respond — Your personal reaction

Personal connection and critical judgement · max. 250 characters

What is your honest personal response? Did this work change the way you think? What does it remind you of? How do you judge it as a critic?

💡 Start with: "I find myself…", "This questions me…", "I think…", "The work made me think of…", "I am struck by…"

Checkpoint 5 — Did the work change how you think? "Did the work change the way you think? In what way?" (max. 150 chars)

Step 4 — The Critique Sentence

Question · Final synthesis · Checkpoint 6

Write one sentence that captures your entire critique.

Imagine a critic writing for an art magazine — concise, bold, precise. Max. 100 characters.

Examples:
"Starry Night is a visual cry of solitude and hope, simultaneously."
"Magritte challenges us to question reality through impossible juxtaposition."
"Vermeer captures interiority itself — a single glance says everything."

0 / 100

Your Group Critique — Art Magazine Banner

✅ Saved! Tagged "Group B — Art Critic — " in your group portfolio.

← Task 4 Continue to Discovery →

What happens in Task 5

A 15-minute Phase 3 Investigation activity for Group B — The Art Critic. Students choose one of six masterworks from a curated gallery, observe it in 60 seconds of silence, then complete the DEAR framework (Describe / Examine / Analyse / Respond) with per-letter checkpoints and sentence starters. The activity concludes with a single Critique Sentence (max. 100 chars) and auto-generates a visual magazine-style output banner saved to the group portfolio.

📋 Six Assessment Checkpoints

CP1 — Why did you choose this work? (80 chars · after artwork selection)

CP2 — Most important detail in your description? (100 chars · after D)

CP3 — How does the artist guide your gaze? (120 chars · after E)

CP4 — Central emotion or message? (150 chars · after A)

CP5 — Did the work change how you think? (150 chars · after R)

CP6 — Does your critique sentence summarise the DEAR well? (Validation before save)

👥 Suggested Group Roles

Detail Observer — Leads D (careful observation of colours, shapes, technique)

Structural Analyst — Leads E (organisation, movement, balance)

Meaning Interpreter — Leads A (symbolism, intention, historical context)

Personal Spokesperson — Leads R (emotional response and personal critique)

Facilitator/Editor — Coordinates, validates coherence, edits the Critique Sentence

♿ SEN Adaptations

Sentence starter examples visible as placeholder text in all DEAR fields (disappear when writing begins)
Voice input available on all text fields — student narrates; platform converts to text
Student with writing difficulty partners with a stronger student (not isolated) — shared form supported
Save as Draft button: preserves incomplete session without losing progress
Audio narration of instructions available per field (sound icon)
Extended time: +1 minute per DEAR letter available via accessibility settings
High contrast mode and larger font available site-wide
Reduce motion option disables all entry animations
Zoom / digital magnifier on artwork display (up to 400%)

🖨️ No-Tech Format

High-quality printed reproduction (A3 or larger) of the chosen artwork — one per group, or rotated between groups
Printed DEAR sheet with 4 structured fields: blank space for drawing/writing per letter
Artist context card (back of sheet): Who / When / Movement / 3–4 lines of context
Pocket DEAR guide (small card with sentence starters per letter, laminated for reuse)
Group surrounds reproduction in silence (60 sec) — no talking
Phase D: Each student points out one element → one student writes on the sheet
Phase E: Discussion "Where does your gaze start?" → notes made collaboratively
Phase A: Teacher reads artist context card → group discussion about meaning
Phase R: Individual reflection whispered to a partner → combined notes on sheet
Final critique sentence written collectively — spokesperson reads it aloud in Phase 5

Progress0%

Choose a masterpiece

60s silent observation

Complete DEAR analysis

Write critique sentence

Save to group portfolio

🔬

Analysing

— not yet chosen —

DEAR Progress

DESCRIBE

EXAMINE

ANALYSE

RESPOND

All Tasks — Lesson 2

What is Art?

How Artists Communicate

What Do You See?

Group A — Art Historian

Group B — Art Critic

Group C — The Creator

Art in My World

My Art Statement

Group Gallery

Class Wonder Map

Summative Test